Frankly, I like this Horror-Slasher Peter Pan based bloodbath. Ok, the story is not particularly convincing, but that is not really the point of this kind of movie. I love how they have kept pretty much all characters of the original in this movie but all of them horribly twisted and deformed. For the rest, it is a "Die Hard" bloodbath, which is the point of this kind of movie. Clearly, if you do not like blood and completely over the top characters, this is not for you. If you can see the fun in radical slasher movies, this is one of the better ones. Enjoy.

Very creepy vibes and surprisingly brutal.

I went in with the lowest of expectations, but I was surprised it was a decent film. The kills were bloody and brutal and the acting and script was good. This is by far the best Disney movies horror remake so far.

In my recent binge of trashy horror movies based on formerly copyrighted characters, Peter Pan’s Neverland Nightmare ended up being a pleasant surprise—it’s actually pretty decent. The movie doesn’t try to be clever or reinvent the genre; instead, it embraces being a straightforward slasher set against a creative, twisted backdrop. The concept alone is what sells it, and thankfully, the execution holds up just enough to make it worth the watch. Sure, there are better slashers out there, and it’s still far from high art, but if you’re reading this, then you’re probably intrigued by the idea—and in that case, it delivers exactly what you’re looking for. Rating: 2/5 – 65% – Not Recommended to Everyone

I don't think they come much darker or indeed redder than that. Not a bad watch.