A highly romanticised version of the Superman mythos, and a continuation of the first two originał Reeve films. Singer adheres to a lot of elements from these films, perhaps a little too much as he attempts to continue a story over 25 years old. There is a distinct melancholic feel to the film as Superman's sense of being an outsider and need to connect is emphasised, but this is brought full circle in a twist that many didn't like, but makes perfect thematic sense and allows for a touching heartfelt scene at the end. Whilst Singer also struggles with the Clark/Lois relationship owing to the story needs, he gets the Superman/Lois scenes right and these form the emotional backbone of the film. The complaint of a lack of action is moot as there is plenty of it with a stunning plane rescue sequence being the highlight and an emphasis on Superman saving people rather than simply fighting (take note Man of Steel) although Luthor's plan is again ridiculous. The flying sequences are often beautiful to watch, a minor quibble being the overuse of CGI to depict Superman. Both Routh and Bosworth do a fine job, if a little imitative of Reeve and Kidder, and it is a shame they don't get more to do as Lois and Clark as their characters don't get the chance to display the spark and fun seen in the originals. John Ottman's score wisely includes William's themes, but he adds enough of his own memorable moments that are in keeping with these themes. Ultimately this forms a nice if imperfect trilogy with the Reeve classics.

Simon Massey's review is spot on. In summary, makes a very natural trilogy for the Christopher Reeve Superman 1 and 2 films. This is far superior to the horrendously dark and displeasing Man of Steel. It isn't perfect by any means. I like most of the cast, I like the atmosphere, but I could do with less romanticism. It's crying out for an extended cut to give it that final oomph. And the scenes of Superman flying are a real treat for someone who grew up with Reeve and Cain as his supermen. The use of the original John Williams score is excellent too. 7.25/10

When Kal Penn (Harold and Kumar) plays a henchman, you know the casting wasn’t perfect. While Lex Luther’s evil plot, is like Superman 1 all over again. Still, Kevin Spacey is way better than Jesse Eisenberg as Lex Luther. While the film has it’s moments of excitement and heart. It’s also better than Superman 3-4 at least. The problem is that we have had Lex villain enough. It was time for Brainiac on the big screen finally. Brainiac would have went good with Superman trying to find any sign of Krypton life. Otherwise this still a nice movie even if it won’t blow you away

Brandon Routh makes an amazing superman, with Kevin Spacey as the perfect foil to this. I finally decided to watch this movie, and I was not displeased at all. At the time of release, I thought this would not be so good. I was wrong. I'm also glad that this Superman will be seen in the Arrowverse.