Stanley Andrews

Captain William Kidd (uncredited)

Wade Boteler

Captain of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)

Jimmy Dime

Pirate (uncredited)

Leslie Fenton

Narrator (voice) (uncredited)

Oscar 'Dutch' Hendrian

Pirate (uncredited)

Charles Irwin

First Mate Palmer (uncredited)

Edward LeSaint

Member of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)

Jack Roper

Pirate (uncredited)

Charles Sullivan

Member of Captain Kidd's Crew (uncredited)

Ian Wolfe

Skeptical Member of Modern-day Expedition (uncredited)