Loved the concept and the first episode kept me wanting more, the Martin's are funny and Selena works very well with them. It's a slow paced type of show, so not sure if many will like it, of course the 10/10 is my opinion and how entertained I was by this. Give it a shot

Went into this show expecting a fun time and while I definitely received that the outcome was something much more special. What a consistently surprising mystery with an excellent mix of humor brought to life by many incredible actors who have impeccable chemistry with one another. All three leads are coming for Emmy nominations and no one can stop them. Hands down one of the best shows of the year so far.

Fairly mediocre and much less than it could have been. I bailed after the 6th episode. - Every now and then it made half-hearted attempts to drift back to the mystery. - Way too many scenes were simply Martin and Short just trying to be cute together. Very lazy writing - Gomez was given a lot of mediocre scenes when not with the old guys. I am still shocked that this got the glowing reviews that it did

It's not as good as I was expecting, but still giving it more time to improve. Got to episode 3 and it's worth continuing - just don't expect a ton of laughs. Martin Short is definitely the best actor in the show, with Steve Martin surprisingly not quite up to his best. Selena Gomez should stick to singing 'cause she certainly can't act. Overall it's amusing and worth spending time watching - looking forward to the mystery unfolding. 7/10 (8/8/22) Season 2 - Getting stupider by the episode. Complete mess compared to season 1 - 4/10

The only way I can describe this show is 'meh'. I really wanted to love it, but I just couldn't. The humour constantly missed the mark for me, and I think this might be Selena Gomez at her worst - her performance was so stiff and dull, as though she were a robot pretending to be a person. It was really bad. Can't recommend it.