When their father dies, the slick and charming Terry has to reluctantly partner up with his socially awkward brother Peter to save the comic book store they inherited—or lose everything to Dad's arch-enemy.

When Terry and Peter accidentally give away a comic worth thousands, they risk the beating of a lifetime from its rightful owner. Even worse, if they can't get it back, they could lose the store.

Terry feels like his mojo with ladies is fading just as he needs it most – because this time he doesn't have to get a date for himself, he has to guide Peter through one.

When Terry takes Peter for granted one too many times, Peter goes on strike. At first, business savvy Terry thinks running the place will be a breeze, but creepy kids and a deranged delivery guy quickly make him realize Peter is the glue that holds the insanity of the store together.

When Terry invites Peter's childhood hero to do a signing, Peter's thrilled... that is, until he discovers his 'hero' is a crazy, violent, dream-crushing drunk.

When the duo stage a break-in for publicity, they end up in the middle of accidental crime spree that can only be solved by one last heist.

When Bernie's new Mr. Right just might turn out to be Mr. Dangerously and Criminally Wrong, Terry and Peter have to step up and sabotage the love life of their best friend.

Terry gets an offer that could take him away from the mall, just as Peter is about to face the biggest fight of his life... in costume.