NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE NOPE Can't beat the original.

It’s not about beating the original and its not even trying to beat the original. Its about the memories and the nostalgia if you grew up with the original. There’s been sequels without the original actors back, this is definitely better and funnier than those.

I didn't even know there is an original version of this movie. Regardless, I'm disappointed in HBO Max. This movie and A Hollywood Christmas and maybe many other are simply disappointing. Such poor productions. I'd rather re-watch Six Feet Under which is a great show.

"A Christmas Story Christmas" is a respectful, if safe, sequel that warmly embraces its roots. While it doesn’t surpass the original’s cult status, it succeeds as a touching tribute, blending humor and heartache. Ideal for fans seeking holiday comfort food, it’s a worthy addition to seasonal rotations, proving that some traditions—even revisited ones—still spark joy.

A loving tribute to the original, _A Christmas Story Christmas_ is a heartwarming and magical family film. All grown up now, Ralphie Parker takes his wife and children back to his hometown to be with his mother for Christmas following the death of his father, and tries to give them a perfect Christmas the way his father used to do for him. Peter Billingsley reprises his role as Ralphie and is joined by Erinn Hayes and Julie Hagerty. And there are several cameos by other original cast members, including Scott Schwartz, R.D. Robb, and Zack Ward. Co-written by Billingsley, the film does a good job at honoring and calling back to the first film without feeling forced or disingenuous, and the comedy is well-done, with some clever satire about the holidays. _A Christmas Story Christmas_ is a worthy sequel that captures a bit of the magic that made the original a beloved classic.