Andrew Garfield

Prior Walter/The Man In The Park

Nathan Lane

Roy M. Cohn/Prior 2

Susan Brown

Hannah Pitt/Rabbi Chemelwitz/Roy's Doctor/Ethel Rosenberg

Denise Gough

Harper Pitt/Martin Heller

Amanda Lawrence

The Angel/The Voice/Nurse Emily/Sister Chapter/Homeless Woman

James McArdle

Louis Ironson

Nathan Stewart-Jarrett

Belize/Mr. Lies

Russell Tovey

Joseph Pitt/Prior 1/The Eskimo

Stuart Angell

Angel Shadow

Laura Caldow

Angel Shadow