Everyone is saying they loved the first one, but hated this one. I don't see how that's possible. They stuck very close to the original in most ways, such as cinematography, soundtrack, and directing, all of which were great (for a Sin City movie). Sure it isn't a masterpiece my any means, and it's not as good as the first, but it's super entertaining, very violent, and is sure to please anyone who enjoys the books or the first film. Forget all those jaded movie snobs saying it sucks. They're just focusing on all the negatives, and letting that cloud their vision of the awesome stuff.

I think it's OK. Many scenes are too slow or long. In the first the short scenes helped the comic style and pace. Scenes in this also didn't have the impact of the first, which often ended in creative violence or cheesy noir one liners. This movie is slower and has less impact. It needed a great story to make up for the sacrifices. We didnt get one. The story also felt disjointed at some points. It seemed the best of the cast wasn't used and the worst were. I can see why it flopped. It starts off good and gets progressively less interesting.

Visually stunning. That's what I love most about Sin City. Eva Green's scenes were utterly breathtaking! Her beauty was a great addition to this sequel.

Didn't enjoy it at all. I wasn't a huge fan of the first movie but thought it was entertaining. I didn't have expectations to high when I went to watch this sequel. The visuals are still the same as the first but I suppose the flare is gone after you have seen it before and know what to expect. The plot, acting, and action scenes just do not offer enough to keep my interest. It seems the director thought as much too since they shove Eva Green's excellent boobs down your throat through out the movie. Don't get me wrong, I am a typical guy and love the boob shots, but a lot of scenes just seemed forced, unnecessary, awkward and out of place. The action scenes are ruined by unnatural movements. You can tell that people are suspended on wires and pulled from this side of the set to the other. You can not let your imagination accept it because everyone's movements are so noticeably unnatural. Even in my science fiction I like there to be at least some laws of physics upheld. The plot is not fluid and seems to be mini-plots shoved together to form a long movie of semi related task. Now the movie is not just plain horrible and I am sure if you are a big fan of the first edition then this one will be a fun watch, but there is no way I will be watching it a second time.

Not worthy of a rewatch git ppphhhfffrrrttt