At different times this movie reminded me of ten other rom coms that I've seen. Unfortunately all ten were EASILY better than this movie. This movie has issues all over the place. First, the two male leads are awful. The one has no personality and the other is doing a poor imitation of Robert Redford (it turns out that you can't fake real charm or acting ability, even if you look the part). But the worst part about this movie (and it isn't close) is Stephen Merchant. I've enjoyed his work for many years but they made him a clown in this movie (is there any easier scene to write than a best man speech in a rom com? It was brutal). You can see where the movie is going but when it gets there it just doesn't feel believable. This was a seriously mediocre movie. follow me at https://IHATEBadMovies.com or facebook IHATEBadMovies

I Give It a Year (2013) is a romantic comedy that challenges the usual expectations of the genre. Directed by Dan Mazer, known for his work on Borat, the film focuses on the complications and challenges that arise during the first year of marriage for an unconventional couple. While it adheres to certain classic rom-com tropes, it sets itself apart by incorporating sharp humor and awkward situations that explore the highs and lows of modern relationships. The cast is one of the film’s strongest assets. Rose Byrne and Rafe Spall star as newlyweds Nat and Josh, whose completely opposite personalities create much of the conflict and humor in the story. Anna Faris and Simon Baker, in supporting roles, add an interesting dynamic as the third parties in the mix, balancing emotional moments with comedic relief. The performances are supported by a script that, while not always spot-on, offers clever dialogue and memorable gags. The movie unfolds as a satire of marriage and the unrealistic expectations often placed on life as a couple. Though some moments verge on caricature, it also delivers sharp insights into incompatibility and the struggle to sustain a relationship. However, some comedic twists may feel excessive or overly reliant on cringe humor, which might not appeal to all viewers. Visually, I Give It a Year is appealing, with bright and warm settings that contrast with the script’s more cynical tone. The soundtrack complements the atmosphere but doesn’t particularly stand out. What truly shines is how the film dares to question the norms of the romantic comedy genre, although at times it doesn’t fully commit to its critical approach, leaving viewers with a sense of unfulfilled depth. Overall, I Give It a Year is an entertaining film that strays from the typical rom-com formula with its cynical tone and edgy humor. While it doesn’t always strike the perfect balance between laughs and emotional weight, it offers enough standout moments to make it a worthwhile option for those seeking something different in the genre.

Rafe Spall plays the slubbby loser type of guy in different things I have seen. This movie is full of a lot of failure and awkward moments. He just sits around being a poor husband choice. The humor comes from all the mistakes he is making. He is playing a similar character in his show "Pete versus Life."

Bland and uninspired, I Give It A Year is a rote and stereotypical romantic comedy. Newlyweds Josh and Natasha have their love tested as they discover eccentricities about each other during the course of their first year of marriage, leading them to question whether or not they’ll be able to make it work. Featuring Rose Byrne, Simon Baker, and Anna Faris, the cast is fairly solid. However, the writing is especially poor, and all of the jokes and plot turns can be seen coming from a mile away. I Give It A Year delivers a few laughs, but it’s just too predictable.

Funny in places, have seen better, not recommended. Notting Hill or Love, Actually are better.