Nigel Butler

Himself / Paul / Therapist / Ricky Vance / Nick Sutton

Carl Wager

Jacob Ferguson

Bryan Da Silva

Ebenezer Scrooge

Melissa Lee Fulmer

Della

Peyton Real

Thin Santa Claus

John Applegate

Benny the Elf

Gunnar Dalton

Gordon

Kelly Dinsmore

May Fitch

Joseph Vassallo

Alex

Matthew Easley

Zach Nabors