Richard Ian Cox

Donner

Jimmy Kimmel

Skeezer

Mark Acheson

Blitzen / Cupid / Santa

Mark Hildreth

Dasher / Dancer

Nicole Oliver

Prancer / Vixen

Scott McNeil

Brock / Tubby / Elf DJ / Vocal Coach / Oiled Elf

John R. Taylor

Comet

Tabitha St. Germain

Noelle / Ele Kid / Gigi

Philip Maurice Hayes

Elf Boss / Parrot (credit only)