Coop and Ronald battle it out for Kaleigh's affections in the wrestling ring.

Coop reveals to Tara that he has feelings for Kaleigh. Tara's excited and encourages Coop to tell her... in a magic moment Tara will help him create. But Ronald finds out about their plans and when Tara and Coop attempts to get Kaleigh and Coop alone in court after school, Ronald tells the whole school there's a party there. With Mathers sensing something's up, the gang has to get rid of all the partygoers while Coop tries to find Kaleigh. When he does find her, Howie is busy revealing Ronald's less than honest manipulations and Kaleigh swears off boys before Coop can confess his feelings. Meanwhile, Van tries to keep Mathers away from court till the gang gets rid of the partygoers and Howie and Rusty battle it out in a mini-golf tournament around Banting.

Coop's "purely professional" interest in representing Banting High's Glee Club turns out to be romantic when he meets Glee Club's only member, a girl named Mindy. Meanwhile, Rusty destroys the new Teen Court LCD monitor and must fix it.