Caramoan - Fans vs. Favorites
She Annoys Me Greatly
Returning players are pitted against newcomers on the exotic Caramoan Islands.
Honey Badger
Following the first elimination of the season, Brandon targets Dawn as the leader of what he sees as an unsuitable vote and matchless teamwork and disorganization from one tribe leaves little room for competition during a tiered Immunity Challenge.
There's Gonna Be Hell to Pay
Corinne and Malcolm's special bond leads to a discovery that could liven up the game.
Kill or Be Killed
After a medical emergency, one Castaway's ability to play the game is in danger.
Persona Non Grata
The Favorites must contend with an out-of-control Brandon when he reveals his hidden desire to sabotage their camp.
Operation Thunder Dome
A shake-up with the Tribes creates chaos and new alliances.
Tubby Lunchbox
As the newly formed Bikal Tribe continues to struggle physically in challenges, they grow increasingly tired of Phillip's attitude.
Blindside Time
All bets are off when Bikal and Gota merge, as castaways reunite to plot a potential blindside in the new tribe.
Cut Off the Head of the Snake
One castaway learns a secret that will potentially change the game.
Zipping Over the Cuckoo's Nest
An accident threatens one castaway's future in the game.
Come Over to the Dark Side
The popular food auction returns as the Three Amigos attempt to take control of the game.
The Beginning of the End
Two immunity challenges and two Tribal Councils raise the stakes, forcing castaways to consider big moves.
Don't Say Anything About My Mom
Castaways get a much-needed morale boost with a visit from their loved ones, and one Survivor is faced with a game-changing decision.
Last Push
With the title of Sole Survivor on the line and $1 million within arm's reach, one castaway falls victim to a heartbreaking medical emergency.
Caramoan Reunion
Avis de la communauté (4)
The first Fans vs. Favorites season (Micronesia) was one of the best. They tried to repeat that success here, and didn't quite hit the mark. The largest problem is probably that the Favorites they chose (or managed to get) were, for the most part, not exciting at all. I mean, really, Brandon Hantz? Come on now. Phillip is good for a few laughs, and Cochran is still entertaining. But it was just lacking star power overall. As for how the season played out, it's fine. There's good moments. There's one particularly memorable moment that is definitely not "good," but it was certainly a notable moment of Survivor. I was happy with the winner. This is a perfectly fine season of Survivor, but considering it's a returning player season, it fails to live up to the excitement that those usually entail.
*SPOILERS AHEAD* COCHRAN! That is all that really needs said about this season. Similar to the original Fans vs Favorites, the Favorites kinda dominate. The pre merge wasn't too thrilling, but after? Oh my. Three Amigos, Blindside Andrea, Blindside Brenda. The post merge dominance of Cochran led to an EXTREMELY boring final four...but that's the point. He made moves happen! With all that being said, the cast was not that great in that grand scheme of things. They essentially took the greatest hits for tv ratings of a "lackluster" run of seasons and gave them a chance at redemption: Lackluster "Favorites" Entering the Season: Francesca is a now a two time first evict Phillip is great at tv but not an admiral piece in the game and was never gonna win in either season Brandon Hantz was another person good for tv that stood no chance of winning and was his own demise the first time around Erik was his own demise his first time around on the first Fans vs Favorites with arguably the worst move ever Cochran was a weasel the first time around that did nothing that first time to deserve a chance to return Dawn was screwed by Cochran's flipping the first time around as her most memorable characteristic Corrine is a middle evict from a forgotten season 17. Good "Favorites" Entering the Season: Brenda was blindsided before in her first season Andrea was overshadowed/blindsided by Rob in 22 Malcolm was a back-to-back competitor that was very welcome. So 3 of 10 were "All Star" level going in. That's not really an ideal Fans vs Favorites as someone that appreciates good game play. With that being said, Cochran totally redeemed himself and then some. Phillip was also enjoyable and utilized his "B.R." rules pretty well. I think the irony of most going out how they did was rather fitting. Francesca repeated, Erik/Brandon went out again for things not decided by the tribe, Corrine was a middle evict again, Cochran screwed Dawn at the end once again, and Brenda and Andrea were once again blindsided lol. As far as the fans...I basically forget them all already. The member of The Three Amigos were the only two that will stick, and I will refer to them as Malcolm's left and right hand men. As I write this, I honestly forget who the fan was that made the finale, since she was irrelevant entirely. Anyways, It was an enjoyable season with medical evacs, drama, and a solid winner. Unfortunately, I think the casting could have been better. This is a better "tv season" than "Survivor season" if that makes sense. Still would recommend if you are a fan, especially if you are a sucker for returnees like I am! Rating: 8.5/10
Great season with one of my most favourite winners.