The thing I remember best about the original series was the fantasies that turned out almost opposite to the wishes of the guests. It could be quite dark for a primetime show. Nothing like that here. Only happy endings so far

This is a wonderful throwback/reboot of the original Fantasy Island. There have been a few attempts to reboot this as movies and tv shows but almost always with more of a horror edge. This newest iteration is much more in sync with the original and is quite heartwarming and romantic. Whether this type of show will/can survive in this day and age has yet to be seen. But, I really enjoyed the first season. How I rate: 1-3 ❤ = seriously! don't waste your time 4-6 ❤ = you may or may not enjoy this 7-8 ❤ = I expect you will like this too 9-10 ❤ = movies and TV shows I really love!

It's not perfect, but it's lighthearted entertainment, and, much to ruegnueg's chagrin, it's full of that "woke shit". Queers abound! Hooray!

Not going to lie, I was quite glad this show was cancelled after season 2. This show was difficult to keep up with every week despite being a fan of weekly anthology type of shows. The weekly stories were not always engaging, often quite slow. The show did improve in the second season by putting a larger emphasis on the intertwining plot, however, that is still not enough to make me want a third season. Average Season Review: 6.25/10 Recommendation: Skip (For Short Story Fans)

I loved this show just got into watching it and it's being cancelled, I am disappointed.