Season 1
Table 1: Satan vs. Jesus
Players: Matt Servitto (Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell), Erik Resnick (Senior VP), Gerald "Slink" Johnson (Black Jesus), Drew Himmelreich (Data Analyst), Anca Vlasan (Assembly Line Yeah!), Adam Fuchs (Artist/Animator)
Table 2: Aqua Teen (and Then Some)
Players: Andrew Choe (FishCenter Live), Mary Kraft (Squidbillies), David Willis (Aqua Teen), Brandon Lively (Creative Director), Mike Schatz (Aqua Teen), Dana Snyder (Aqua Teen)
Table 3: Too Many Cooks (and Poker Players)
Players: Elizabeth Cook (Squidbillies), Evan D'Elia (Web Developer), Chris "Casper" Kelly (Too Many Cooks), Keith Crofford (Executive VP), Nick Gibbons (As Seen On Adult Swim), William Tokarsky (Too Many Cooks)
Table 4: Best of the Rest
Players: Ben Amick (Commercial Producer), Duke Nguyen (Producer/Editor), Dave Hughes (Off the Air), David "Doc" Matysiak (Visual Effects Artist), Vanessa Palacios (Promotions), Henry Zebrowski (Your Pretty Face Is Going To Hell)
Championship Table
Players: Dave Hughes (Off the Air), Brandon Lively (Creative Director), Gerald "Slink" Johnson (Black Jesus), Chris "Casper" Kelly (Too Many Cooks), Henry Zebrowski (Your Pretty Face Is Going To Hell), Matt Servitto (Your Pretty Face Is Going to Hell)